I've been hearing about "the Left's war on masculinity" for a long time, but, it's more like the Right has been occupying masculinity, and the Left have been retreating from it.
It's more like, the Right is occupying masculinity, and dictating terms for how men are to behave: aggression over negotiation, competition before cooperation, seeking power over all else, commanding obedience from women, measuring self-worth by sexual prowess and career position. Hierarchies are to be respected, you may jockey for position within one, but never tear one down. Pain is a badge of honor. Make loud noises, stake out territory, get in people's way. Eating meat is mandatory, and killing animals is a noble sport. The ultimate virtue of masculinity is dominance, and you demonstrate it by intimidating, obstructing, or even hurting people who are beneath you. Basically, to be a man, you have to be heartless. Any man who doesn't meet these standards is a pussy, and any man who fights these standards is pussifying their culture.
The center and left is opposed to a lot of these things, and coined the term "toxic masculinity" to describe it so that we can talk about it, and we all know how that can be misread. And usually men who take it on just chip away at these standards one at a time. But most of them buy into the frame that conservatives have set up, that to become less conservative is to become less masculine, and anyone who really wants justice and equality will just have to be OK with being less masculine. We have to accept a lower score in the game they designed. We're all just renting our penises from the Right, and if you vote Democrat they get to keep the cleaning deposit.
Like many of the things they steal and then rent back to us, the Right says the Left wants to steal our penises. And this message seems to work well enough that they keep going back to it.
I don't want to blame anyone, or suggest that anyone involved should have done anything different, but I want to breach the subject of how many leftist YouTubers are trans-feminine. Not all of them, or even most, but more than seems statistically representative. And mostly in the male-to-female direction. Is there any other community or industry where two prominent established personalities, on the scale of 800K-subscriber YouTubers, came out as trans in the same month? As a good skeptic, I know that correlation does not equal causation. But, as a human being who sees patterns and feels emotions, I can't bring myself to completely ignore this.
I'm still grieving for Abigail Thorn's previous persona. For those who don't know her, she hosts the
Philosophy Tube channel and it's been the gold standard of video essays for a few years. Its creator had been living as a man, at least in public, through most of it, and that's when I found the channel. You can still see old videos starring a big handsome dude with a beard who talked about self-driving cars and antifascism and Hegelian dialectics and data harvesting and
fucking the Queen. The production values were outstanding, and the content was well-researched, painstakingly cited, and entertaining. The quality of the content has never faltered since, but during the pandemic, the beard disappeared, and the hair got longer...
She came out in the beginning of 2021 with a video titled "
Identity", the first half of which is narrated by a male actor playing her old iconic persona, reading a script. As she writes it, at live events, men would come up to her and talk about she was their masculine role model because of the wholesome and non-toxic model of masculinity she was giving the world. The video covers what it felt to hear that, but, nobody asked why did those men pick those words? Do you think that's what guys say when they meet Tom Hanks? Leonard Nimoy? Alton Brown? Jon Stewart? I think people who say that are describing a specific need being addressed. I think that men who are trying to be wholesome and non-toxic need to know that that effort doesn't come at the cost of our masculinity or our identity. We need to know that we don't have to rent our penises from the Right, we can grow our own. Her old persona served that role, once upon a time.
Another thing she said in her coming-out video was that presenting as a man felt like trench warfare. That's an apt metaphor, because I felt like I was one of the people she was fighting for. One of her pre-transition videos was titled "
Men Abuse Trauma" and covered the unique problems that men face in abusive relationships, drawing from her own experience. Up to then, every story of abuse I'd heard was from a woman's point of view, and I thought that my lesson was supposed to be "don't abuse women, you male piece of shit." And I'd heard of hen-pecked husbands but that was framed as a norm, fodder for "wife bad" boomer humor. But seeing that story of an (apparent) man suffering an abusive girlfriend, I remembered a certain experience I had straight out of college, a few months where someone turned my virtues against me, used my desire to control me, and put ideas into my head that I'm still trying to excise. The video even takes a brief moment, about 10 minutes in, to take on Jordan Peterson directly,
reading a passage from "12 Rules for Life" about how people who stay in unhealthy relationships are just weak-willed and playing the victim. well, Peterson's army is on the other side of that trench, and now there's one less soldier between me and them.
Maybe YouTube anarchist Thought Slime will be the hero we all need. This male personality came out as non-binary during the She-Ra video but has made the bold choice of "any/all" pronouns. I shall choose "they/them" to illustrate that I too am so young and hip that I drink my yogurt from a tube, but they're about 90% dude. They did a video 10 months ago called "
You Can Date, a non-toxic guide, mostly for hetero-dudes" which contained all the information that would have saved me when I was 25. Back then, all my friends were telling me bullshit like "be yourself" and "just stop looking and it'll happen automatically," and the sex pest industry was trying to teach me how to neg. But Mx Slime covers how to "become a good good dater, while also fulfilling your responsibility not to be a creep, sex weirdo, or girl-botherer." The information in the video is succinct, practical, credible, entertaining, and dare I say, vital.
A few months later, they took on "The
WAR on TRADITIONAL MASCULINITY", that thing this post is about, that thing the Right insists they're defending us from! I can think of nobody better suited to dismantle this frame! It starts strong with some angry reactions to clips of right-wing pundits, mostly talking about the culture of cis men being under attack because all those standards I described at the top there were being challenged. They respond more fully with some logic about how the only way that the concept of "feminized" can be a thing is if gender's a social construct to begin with. Then they go a bit deeper into trans stuff for some reason, but come back to
describing the tyranny of male conformity. I expected them to wrap it up in a way that reassured dudes that we can defend our gender without becoming fascists, and also inspired us to improve solidarity with the other genders, and indeed they did... Pretty good video. But, it stung, just a little, that that video was the one where they officially announced that they're going by "Mildred" for a while.
The right's thesis is "the left will steal your penis." The left's response seems to be "what? penises? who needs those?" Well, I do. I need one.
I'm a man without much gender stuff. I have no urge to change my name or gender, grammatically or otherwise. Growing up, I saw girl stuff as alien. I'm fine with men's clothes, and I dress for comfort. For every weather pattern common to Phoenix, I have several outfits that are the same but with different colors. I've found some color schemes that seem to work well. I pee standing up unless I'm at home and I want to bring electronics in there. I don't have any appreciable feminine traits, but I do fail to perform certain stereotypically masculine obligations. I don't watch sports. I don't play first-person shooters. And I became sexually active very late in life, and didn't remain so.
and I live in fear that there will be a knock on my door, and it'll be the masculinity inspector, and he'll find out I've never played beer pong and confiscate my pronouns. I think that's how my friend from junior high lost theirs.
It seems like an exaggeration, but I think if I posted that shit to any random Discord server, someone would tell me I might be agender or gray-gender or demi-boy. And they might not realize that when they say that, what I hear is "you have failed to be a man, maybe if you search hard enough you'll find a gender you can be good at."
I suppose the thing I'm trying to fight here is, the notion that being a man is something I have to "be good at".
And indeed, being good at masculinity would prove nothing. Look again at Abigail Thorn. She got so good at being a man that fans would compliment her on that very performance. But looking at her videos now, she's gotten just as good at being a woman. Who cares about that anyway; the trans women I know in person are mostly in STEM jobs, and basically wear T-shirts and jeans mostly. I didn't know you could go through all that just to wear different-shaped versions of the same clothing items. They did, and it never occurred to me that they could be criticized on that point.
Abigail named her coming-out video "Identity", and what I took away from that video is that one's identity isn't a self-contained thing. Parts of it are external. We negotiate who we are with the rest of the world. And every trans person who comes out must learn who they are and convince the rest of the world. And the right wants to do the reverse of this process to men: when we say who we are, they want to decide what that means.